You’re driving down the road, approaching an intersection when the light turns yellow. You speed up to make the light, and just as you cross the line, it turns red. Suddenly, you see a small flash out of the corner of your eye. You just got caught by a traffic camera.
Soon after that incident, you’ll receive a ticket in the mail, usually with the option to just go ahead and pay it via postal mail- or you have the choice to show up in court to contest it. But fighting it won’t do you much good when there’s photo evidence. The question is, does getting caught by a camera make you think twice before you run a red light again?
Most people would say yes, if only to avoid having to pay fines or having points added to their driving record, as is the case in many states including Oklahoma. But others feel a camera mounted on a traffic light isn’t as accurate as an actual police officer. Some even claim it’s an invasion of privacy – although I think that’s a difficult argument to make when you’re traveling on public roads.
Opposition to traffic cameras, or red-light cameras, often stems from a lack of understanding of how they work. Most intersections using this technology will have four cameras, one on each corner. The cameras are connected both to triggers in the intersection and to a computer.
When a car passes a trigger when the light is red, it trips the camera, which takes two photos—one of the vehicle just over the line, and one of the vehicle in the middle of the intersection—and sends it to the computer, which records the date and time of the incident. More often than not, the cameras are more accurate than police officers at detecting red light runners.
Here in Oklahoma, we have more than our share of dangerous intersections. In Oklahoma City, Pennsylvania Avenue and Memorial Road has been called the deadliest intersection, with 94 crashes recorded there in a single year.
As of February 2010, the most dangerous intersection in Tulsa was at U.S. Highway 169 and 51st street, according to the Tulsa Police Department (TPD). Between 2007 and that time, police responded to 280 crashes at that one location.
Traffic camera detractors may say just put more traffic cops on the roads to decrease accidents. But the solution isn’t that simple. Due to budget cuts, TPD had to lay off many of its officers, and even temporarily suspended its traffic units altogether. In fact, TPD will no longer respond to non-injury crashes.
This brings up another interesting potential use of red-light cameras—liability. Let’s say someone runs a red light and hits your car, but neither you nor the other driver are injured. If the police have adopted a stance of only responding when there’s an injury – there’s no police report generated at the scene. That means you don’t get a chance to tell *your* side of the story to anyone. How are you going to prove who was at fault so that the other driver’s insurance will cover your damages?
And what if the other driver leaves the scene? That traffic camera photo may be your only salvation when you’re the victim of a hit-and-run driver. This would be especially true if you were a pedestrian hit by a car that ran a red light and then drove away.
Additionally, the increasing prevalence of cell phone-related distracted driving means that ‘accidental’ red light running could become more common, as drivers enter intersections against the light simply because they are not paying attention. And that is behavior that can have truly tragic consequences, as the deaths of Joe Teater and Martha Ovalle show.
Not being able to recover damages creates a liability problem for both individual drivers and those who drive as part of their job – meaning employers could be left footing the bill for non-employee drivers’ erratic behavior. Until cities can afford to have enough traffic cops on duty, or better yet, drivers slow down and use more caution on the roads, traffic cameras may be the best way to deter reckless driving, at least in dangerous intersections.
Noble McIntyre is the senior partner and owner of McIntyre Law, a firm staffed by experienced Oklahoma car crash lawyers.
Images via brewbooks, Noble McIntyre
0 Comments. Add yours »